Have a performance or feedback conversation
When to use
You need to address someone's performance or behaviour and want the conversation to produce real change.
What you'll get
A feedback script that names the specific behaviour and its impact, checks whether the attribution is fair, and signals clearly what change is required โ without softening language that lets the person walk away thinking it wasn't serious.
The prompt
I need a performance or feedback conversation with [ROLE]. The issue: [SPECIFIC BEHAVIOUR OR PROBLEM]. The impact: [IMPACT ON TEAM / WORK / OUTCOMES].
My current explanation for why this is happening: [YOUR CURRENT THINKING].
Before writing the script, check a few things:
- Am I explaining this as a character or attitude problem when the real cause might be situational โ unclear expectations, inadequate support, wrong role, something I haven't asked about? When things go wrong, we tend to attribute them to the person rather than the circumstances. It's worth verifying.
- What I expect of this person, and how I signal those expectations, will shape what they deliver. High expectations communicated clearly tend to produce better outcomes than the same expectations delivered with low confidence.
- The feedback needs to land. The most common reason it doesn't is that it gets softened until the person leaves thinking it wasn't really serious.
Now write a feedback script that names the specific behaviour without attributing it to a character flaw, acknowledges possible situational explanations without letting them off the hook, makes the required change concrete and observable, and signals genuine belief that they can make it.Why this prompt works
The situational check is not about letting the person off the hook โ it's about accuracy. A conversation aimed at fixing a clarity problem when the issue is motivation will fail; so will the reverse.
The psychology behind this
The Fundamental Attribution Error
Read the full experiment โ17_fundamental_attribution_error.mdThe Pygmalion Effect
Read the full experiment โ14_pygmalion.md